EssayAce Analysis — Independent Educational Commentary
Hamilton College
Shiwani Paudel
Shiwani Paudel. Portsmouth, N.H. — Hamilton College Class of 2030. The college published this essay under the student's name and did not give it a separate title.
Last updated:
Source: Hamilton College Admission — Essays That Worked. https://www.hamilton.edu/admission/apply/college-essays-that-worked On this page, read the essay by Shiwani Paudel of Portsmouth, N.H. Hamilton published several Class of 2030 essays together and did not give this one a separate title. EssayAce does not reprint the essay.
- Prompt
- 1. Background, Identity, Interest, or Talent
- The story turns a costume mishap into a claim about identity after years of moving between Nepal, Canada, and the United States. That is a background-and-identity essay. A reader could also file the ending under personal growth, but Hamilton did not print a prompt number.
- Story type
- Costume scene that opens into belonging
- IdentityBelongingCommunity
What the essay is about
The writer is dressed as Hermione at a camp when a younger camper points out that she does not look the part. A fellow camper supplies an improvised explanation that lets her keep the role. She uses that moment to trace a childhood of repeated moves and then shows how she builds a sense of belonging at school, on a team, and at a food pantry where she is much younger than the other volunteers.
Why this essay works
- Opens with a child's blunt question instead of a statement about being an outsider.
- Uses the same costume image at the end without replaying the punchline.
- Keeps the writer's own voice: a mix of humor, observation, and a clear sense of where she came from.
What works
The opening scene is funny and specific, so the theme arrives as a consequence rather than a thesis. The later examples do different work: school, team, and pantry are three versions of the same question, and none repeats the costume joke.
Personal voice
She keeps the awkwardness of the camp moment instead of smoothing it into a lesson. The voice is someone who can laugh at the costume and still notice exactly who stepped in to help.
Storytelling
A single exchange starts the essay. The middle is a sequence of short scenes rather than a list of moves, and each scene ends with a decision to stay or join rather than a statement about resilience.
Reflection
The insight is that belonging is not sameness. She holds onto the fact that she is different even as she describes the people who made room for her, which keeps the ending from becoming a simple thanks-to-my-community close.
Structure
Costume scene, a rewind to childhood moves, three present-tense examples, then a return to the original question with a narrower answer.
Lessons
- 01A small, slightly comic scene can carry a serious claim about identity if you let the characters speak.
- 02If you write about moving or fitting in, choose two or three places and show a different kind of welcome in each.
- 03Say what still feels different at the end. Belonging is more believable when it does not erase the difference.
Unofficial EssayAce reading
These words are EssayAce's educational commentary on the published essay. They are not points, not a grade out of 100, and not a score from Hamilton College or any admissions office.
- Personal Voice
- Distinctive
- Story & Specificity
- Concrete
- Reflection & Insight
- Earned
- Prompt Relevance
- Close fit
- Structure & Writing
- Shaped
Official prompt this reading uses
Prompt 1 (2026–2027). “Some students have a background, identity, interest, or talent that is so meaningful they believe their application would be incomplete without it. If this sounds like you, then please share your story.”
Also plausible: Prompt 5, Personal Growth or Realization. The library files the essay once, under the closer prompt.
Sources and citations
EssayAce analysis cites the primary sources below. The student essay is not reproduced here; read it on the college site.
- 1. Hamilton College Admission — Essays That Worked, “Shiwani Paudel” by Shiwani Paudel, published by Hamilton College. https://www.hamilton.edu/admission/apply/college-essays-that-worked On this page, read the essay by Shiwani Paudel of Portsmouth, N.H. Hamilton published several Class of 2030 essays together and did not give this one a separate title.
- 2. Common App essay prompts. https://www.commonapp.org/apply/essay-prompts/
- 3. UNC admissions reprint of the 2026–2027 Common App prompts. https://admissions.unc.edu/application-prompts-for-2025-2026/
- 4. EssayAce essay analysis rubric. https://college-essay-grader.com/blog/common-app-essay-examples
EssayAce Analysis — Independent Educational Commentary. This page is a paraphrase and a craft reading. The student's sentences stay on the college's page.
Free Essay Grader
How does your essay compare?
Found an essay style you like? See how your own essay compares.
EssayAce scores a draft you paste in. That result is independent writing feedback, not an admissions decision and not a score from any college.
More essays
- The Two Sides of America
Gillian H. · Prompt 1
- The Secret Ingredient is Connection
David M. · Prompt 1
- Considering a physical feature and its role in your identity
Nikeya Tankard · Prompt 1